Thursday, November 13, 2008

Virtual Schools

How would you determine the readiness of students to participate in distance delivery?
Students who are interested in distance education must not feel the need to be a part of a class in the traditional sense. They need to be self-motivated with fantastic time-management skills. They must be able to understand material without direct class discussion and must have a basic understanding of technology. Students must also have patience for technology and understand that things may potentially go wrong so they must plan ahead. If a student generally waits until the last minute to complete assignments, they may not be ready for distance education. Students must have the required technology to use virtual education and time and energy to put forth on this type of education.

What would you need to do to be able to teach in a virtual school?
A virtual teacher is required to have a bachelor’s degree in education as well as some teaching experience. They also need experience in the technology field. However, not all teachers need to be national board certified. A very small percentage of the teachers at Florida Virtual School are national board certified (scary!).
It is important that virtual school teachers are able to remain excited while teaching in this environment. Since there is no student/teacher interaction, it is difficult to connect with students and know their learning styles. Teachers must be able to find a way to work around these obstacles and teach to each individual student.



Pros to Virtual Schools
1. Virtual schools provide an individualized approach to learning. Students can create their own learning plan and find a method that works for them. If students are not doing well in the traditional school environment, a virtual school may be more effective because it can be tailored to fit each individual student.
2. Virtual schools provide education for accelerated learners. Some students do not do well in the traditional school atmosphere because they are “gifted” and thus are not challenged at school. Virtual schools may be more suitable to challenge these students and give them the advanced education that they need.
3. Virtual schools provide an alternative for students who are not fit for the typical school setting. Some students struggle with the traditional school system for other reasons. If a student is not succeeding in the traditional setting, a virtual school may be more suitable. Sine they can tailor their program, and do it from home, they may be able to receive and education that they otherwise may miss out on. This could keep struggling students in school or provide an education for a student who cannot leave the house due to illness or cannot go to traditional school due to constant relocating etc. This may also be an option for teen mothers who need to stay home with their children or students that need to work to support their family and would otherwise miss out on an education.
4. Virtual schools allow students to tap into courses anytime, anywhere. For students who cannot be at school at a specific time everyday, virtual schools are ideal. They are able to do their schoolwork anywhere they have access to a computer. They do not have to sit down and do it in one consecutive block of time. This may suit some students better than the traditional method of education.
5. Virtual schools are tuition free. Since virtual schools are public, they do not cost anything. However, students must be able to afford a computer to work on. The cost of the schooling is nonexistent but there are other costs involved.

Cons to Virtual Schools
1. Virtual schools require more time than traditional schools. Students must be able to manage their time to complete the work. This is both a con and a pro because time-management skills are very important for students. This may be difficult for some students who are not used to this different method of schooling. It is easy to leave all of the work to the end of the semester since students are able to set their own pace. Students must be sure that they are able to finish all of the work by the final deadline.
2. Virtual schools require self-discipline and commitment that some Elementary students have not yet developed. These are not for students who are indecisive and unable to stick to something. Virtual schools are difficult and require commitment from the student as well as the family. If the family does not support their child in this alternative method of education, it could be very difficult for the child to succeed. Self-discipline is an important trait to have in life, but many students have not yet learned how to push themselves without a teacher’s influence. Students who do not possess this trait will not be able to succeed in a distance education program. Their parents or guardians must keep their children on track and help teach them the self-discipline required for distance education and life. If parents do not teach this, students will not be able to utilize virtual schools.
3. Virtual schools do not have face to face student-teacher interaction. Without this direct interaction, students do not form the relationship with their teachers that they are able to form in the traditional classroom. This relationship is an important part of a child’s schooling. Education is not only about the curriculum material, it is about relationships and life skills. I am worried that virtual schools do not teach these important things to children.
4. Virtual schools do not provide the socialization that students receive in traditional schools. A big part of elementary school is learning how to make friends and socialize with other students. Since virtual skills do not provide direct student interaction, children may not learn how to interact properly with others. It is very important that, if a child chooses distance education, they are given the opportunity to socialize and learn these important skills. These social skills are necessary in many aspects of life and are important to form in school.
5. In a virtual school environment, students may not always complete their own work. There is very little accountability in this respect. For example, a student is able to have a parent or friend complete the work and submit it as their own. In this case, the student is not benefitting or learning any of the material and their education is pointless.

4 comments:

Mallory & Lindsey said...

I completely agree with your first paragraph about determining if students are ready for distance education. Time management and motivation are two huge assets necessary for success in an online class. Students must have knowledge of and patience with technology so that they can deal with possible problems that may arrive. I agree with you when you say that it is important that teachers are able to stay motivated and excited about teaching while teaching online. Teachers need to be creative and able to work to learn about each student as an individual.

Amanda said...

With the first question, I hadn't thought about having patience, but I completely agree that patience is a needed factor in not only the student, but in the teacher as well. I also talked about having motivation that is needed in the student in order to be in programs like these. I also agree that virtual schools take more time than traditional schools because they might wait until the end of the semester to do their homework. The student must be responsible enough to handle this type of education.

Cam said...

I think that you bring up a very valid point in this post. This being that the majority of the teachers at Florida Virtual School were not national board certified. This is very disturbing to think that this highly praised program doesn't have certified educators working there.

Jolano said...

Certainly an interesting perspective, but I wonder where you gathered your information about Florida Virtual School?

I contacted the school AND looked on their web site to learn that your statement about certified teachers at Florida Virtual School is flat-out wrong.

All teachers at FLVS are certified in their subject area and 12.6% of the teachers at FLVS are nationally board certified. Compare this to traditional school where only about 6.7% of teachers are nationally board certified; it’s highly unlikely that all their teachers are certified in the subject area they are teaching.

There are two other areas where it appears you’ve jumped to conclusions.

- Socialization: Please talk to the students and parents and ask them if online programs provide opportunities to build friendships. Many programs have student clubs that provide both online and F2F networking opportunities; hold real-time or synchronous discussions with classmates; and online forums that engage students in discussion using an interactive, online whiteboard setting. Today’s students rely on their digital networks to stay in touch using text, chat, IM, email, etc. Building relationships virtually is second nature to many of them and online learning is a natural extension. Good virtual schools create opportunities for students to collaborate on projects or join clubs.

- Academic Integrity: A simple Google search would have given you some sobering facts about cheating in general – 70% of high school and 75% of college students have admitted to cheating…in a traditional classroom setting. Most online programs are created with specific checks and balances to authenticate the student work and use tools, like Turnitin.com, to catch such unethical practices.